Maguire would not get drawn into the debate about who would replace Mbye at left centre, but Paul Momirovski, a left-centre specialist, looks to have the early jump on new recruit Adam Doueihi.
Because Mbye was expected to spend time at hooker while Billy Walters was given a spell, Maguire will now need to shuffle his bench, including the likely inclusion of Reynolds to play that back-up dummy-half role.
Doueihi could yet miss out entirely for the Dragons’ clash, especially given he arrived at the club late and has spent most of his time training at fullback and five-eighth.
Speaking about Reynolds’ effort against the Warriors, Maguire said: “I thought it was an improved performance from the week before, and the things I asked him to work during the week he did which was great.
Maguire added he could not fault the performances of his new recruits, including the Leilua brothers and Doueihi. He was particularly impressed with Leilua and David Nofoaluma’s combination on the right edge.
While the Tigers spent the weekend in New Zealand, they also kept a close eye on their round-one opponents the Dragons, or more specifically new fullback Zac Lomax and how he fared a couple of times under the high ball.
Expect Luke Brooks and Benji Marshall to send plenty of aerial traffic to Lomax.
The Warriors are also sweating on skipper Roger Tuivasa-Sheck, Agnatius Paasi and Kodi Nikorima, who all suffered minor ankle injuries on Sunday against the Tigers.
South Sydney lost impressive prop Patrick Mago to a pectoral tear, despite an impressive second-half effort in the Charity Shield where he scored a try and set up another.
Melbourne prop Nelson Asofa-Solomona is dealing with a hamstring issue and in some doubt to play Manly in round one, with Brandon Smith (facial fractures) and Christian Welch (knee) also out.
Christian covers rugby league for The Sydney Morning Herald.